To download a PDF file of this update, click here
Cars, Consent, and Columbo:
Consent Searches During Motor Vehicle Stops
Legal Question of The Week
Vol. 2, Number 19
August 28, 2009
Brian Beasley
Fan of Detective Television Shows and Legal Adviser, HPPD
In that golden era of television referred to as “The 70’s,”1 there was a certain crime fiction series that featured the character of Lieutenant Columbo, a scruffy looking, shabbily dressed2 homicide detective whose fumbling, absentminded, overly polite demeanor made him an unlikely candidate to solve ANY crime, much less a complex murder. However, his demeanor was a complex put-on, designed to lull suspects into a false sense of security. Columbo was in fact a brilliant detective with an eye3 for minute details who would lull criminals into a false sense of security and then set up circumstances that would cause them to incriminate themselves.
Columbo, played by the great Peter Falk,4 was probably most famous for his signature interrogation technique known as “the false exit.” The detective would conduct a seemingly innocuous interview, politely conclude it and exit the scene only to stop in the doorway, turn around and say “One more thing…” The “one more thing” was always a question that caught the suspect off guard, usually resulting in the suspect accidentally revealing incriminating information. This method will feature prominently in our legal update today.5 Read More
- The 70’s also featured great shows like WKRP in Cincinnati, Mork and Mindy, Charlie’s Angels, and Buck Rodgers in the 25th Century. ↩
- Any resemblance to current High Point Police Detectives is strictly an accident or a product of the new dress code coupled with the current “mustache competition.” ↩
- The actor who played Columbo had a glass eye, so when I say he had “an eye for minute details,” I mean literally that. AN eye. As in one, not two. ↩
- Those of you too young to remember Columbo may know Peter Falk from his equally impressive role of grandfather/narrator in “The Princess Bride.” ↩
- Alongside several more random references to Detective Columbo – stay tuned. ↩
